I’ve mentioned in other
reviews that anime studios pull the same stunts that Hollywood studios do.
You’ll get multiple studios attempting to tell similar stories in a couple
years span. I saw it first hand with the space cowboy boom of the 90s that gave
us Cowboy Bebop, Outlaw Star and Trigun. But it happened more recently with two series that tackled
the concept of pulling a group of gamers into their favorite video game. I
watched Sword Art Online a few years
back and enjoyed it well enough. But a friend of mine told me to check out Log Horizon. It came out a year later
and took things in a unique direction.
Summary:
One minute Shiroe (Takuma
Terashima) was playing the video game Elder Tales, the next minute he was in
the game. He is not alone. Anyone who was playing the game at that moment suffered the same fate. For some players this is a dream come true, for
others it is nightmare. As the players begin to explore the world and learn how
the new rules work they realize one thing – they can’t be killed. This opens up
all kinds of ways characters can exploit the game and each other.
Shiroe is a strategist but
he is also a decent guy. He joins forces with like-minded players in attempt to
bring some order to the chaos around him. But new wrinkles appear where he
least expects them. Are the non-player characters more than simple programs?
Why does all the food in the game taste like stale crackers? Where did all the
newbie players disappear to? And will the Goblin King quest still run even if
no one is playing participating? Joining him in his journey is the cute ninja assassin
Akatsuki (Emiri Kato), the loud and horny warrior Naotsugu (Tomoaki Maneno),
and the elegant cat duelist Nyanta (Jouji Nakata). Together they form a team
that will change the shape of the world. The guild’s name is Log Horizon.
Good Points:
- Creates a detailed world of game rules and mechanics – then uses them as story elements
- The story elements come together to create some surprising moments in the series
- Isn’t afraid to slow things down and have a key climax occur at the negations table instead of the battlefield
Bad Points:
- The visuals, sound and music are all pretty average
- Some of the characters fall into obvious anime tropes that are a little tired
- Viewers who haven’t enjoyed or don’t enjoy role playing video games may find this series difficult to get into
Overall:
Log Horizon
isn’t about the action and adventure of questing in the world of Elder Tales.
It is about how people deal with this surprising shift of realities. At first
the series feels like it is going into too much depth on how this fictional video
game is played and how players interact with each other. But as the series
continues you realize that many of the throw away episodes were actually
building up to the big turning points in the series. Shiroe is an interesting
character, one that thrives on challenge and uses his brain to overcome
obstacles and help others. The series is worth a watch for anyone who enjoys role-playing
video games and doesn’t mind a series that goes light on action but heavy on
dialogue and strategy.
Scores
(out of 5)
Visuals: 3
Sound: 3
Acting: 4
Script: 4
Music: 3
Direction: 4
Entertainment: 4
Total: 4
In Depth Review
The horizon that inspired the team name. |
Here is an example. When the
players eat food in the game, they notice that it all tastes like dry stale
crackers. All the wine, beer, or
fruit juice tastes like water. But isolated ingredients have flavor. So if you
pick up an apple and eat it, it tastes like an apple. But if you eat an apple
pie – it tastes like stale crackers. Pretty darn annoying.
But our resident cat-man
duelist, Nyanta, has a chef skill in the game. He discovers that if he uses the
regular player menus to make the apple pie – stale crackers. But if he actually
attempts to make the pie with his own paws, step by step, it tastes wonderful.
Turns out that if you use the menus you get only the bare minimum of the skill
you attempt to use. But if you physically attempt the task, and if you have a
high enough skill level in the game, you can achieve amazing results. This
doesn’t just go for food, but for any skill – including combat skills.
The setting is a mix of fantasy and modern decay, |
In order to do this concept
justice the series moves pretty slowly. You get a whole episode focusing on
game mechanics, so you get an idea of how a round of combat works in the old
game and how it works in this new world. You get about half an episode talking
about in game communication and how players can speak telepathically (using an
texting type feature) but non-players characters cannot use that skill and see
it as magic. Then you have the reveal that even though the players can’t truly
die in the game, if they are “killed”, when they respawn in the cathedral, they
actually lose some of their memories of their previous life.
Log Horizon
has whole episodes that are mostly discussion and planning. Shiroe puts
together the pieces of his latest puzzle and then executes his plan. We watch
it all fall into place (or even go in an unexpected direction a couple times). Some
of the most impressive plot climaxes are negotiations and political
outmaneuvering. It is a rare thing to see in a fantasy series of any type. And
I admit, I found the change of pace refreshing.
Akatsuki leads the charge into action! |
There is a drawback to this
approach, and it comes in uneven pacing. I enjoyed the variety, but I can see
some people finding the series too slow or filled with padding (which I would
argue isn’t the case at all). The slice of life episodes do an interesting duel
task of developing characters and telling us more about the world and game
mechanics.
A hero or evil genius? |
Some of the other characters
refer to him as the Super Villain because of his plotting and planning. And
like any good strategist, Shiroe attempts to see several moves into the huge chess
game. Part of the fun of watching Log
Horizon is seeing how these plans play out and how far Shiroe planned and
had contingencies in place.
Yes there is a lovely princess, but will she help or hinder the players? |
Naotsugu is the hulking
warrior who is also a bit of a clown. Here is another character they could have
delved into a bit. But mostly he’s around to hit on the girls, make comments
about breast size and get kicked in the face by an offended Akatuski.
Rounding out the guild is
the cat-man Nyanta. He’s debonair, skilled with the blades and a pretty good dancer.
He seems to be Shiroe’s trusted advisor. But other than him saying “Nyan”
(which is Japanese for Meow) a lot we don’t get to know too much about him.
Instead we have a second
tier of adventurers in Log Horizon
who we get to know a little bit better. They are newbies that Shiroe encounters
early in the series and they end up taking up larger role as the series
progresses. This is fine because they are actually pretty interesting. Minori
(Nao Tamura) leads this other band. We learn a lot about the game and the world
through her eyes as a new player. She idolizes Shiroe, and following his
teachings she becomes a valuable member of the guild. I liked her interactions
with her brother Toya (Daiki Yamashita). In the real world he was confined to a
wheelchair, but here he is a samurai with some impressive skills. The series
could have dug a little more into that, but what you get is enough to invest
you with these two.
Players can see the stats for everyone they meet. |
That said there is no main
villain in Log Horizon. There are
challenges that the group and Shiroe face. Sometimes they come in the form of a
physical threat, like the Goblin King in the middle the series. But most of the
time they revolve around working with or against other players. Or dealing with
the non-player characters like kings and merchants. Unfortunately, the final
story arc is little hollow because it feels like it is all set up for
Season 2.
The visual design of the
series is solid but nothing that really stands out. It looks like they took a
standard Japanese role playing game and used that style for the clothing
and character appearance. It seems a little slap dash in places and certainly
lacks the intriguing details of something like Vision of Escaflowne or Record
of Lodoss War.
Even though players can't die, there are consequences for losing a battle. |
Sound work is pretty
much were you expect them to be. Some cool sounding effects for the magic
attacks and the fantasy creatures. Plenty of clashing and clanging for the
swords on armor battles. The music by composer Yasuharu Takanashi is solid.
There is a theme that reoccurs for our heroes. It supports the scenes well
enough, even getting a little silly for the slapstick moments (which are
usually when the perv Naotsugu is getting kicked in the face by Akatsuki). A
good score but not one that grabbed me like Yoko Kanno’s wonderful work on Vision of Escaflowne. But that may be
the gold standard for anime fantasy music.
The Japanese acting works
fine. The voices seem to fit the characters, and some of them are obviously
having a really good time. There is an English dub of the first season, but I
didn’t get a chance to sample it.
Cat man vs. electro man! Cat man will prevail! |
So yeah, I’m keen to see the
next season. There are plenty of great story opportunities there. As I
mentioned many of the characters have great potential for interesting stories
too, so I hope we get beyond the tropes that were established in the first
season. But I’ve learned one thing from anime series sequels and that is you
usually get more of the same. But in this case that will be fine, because
season one was very entertaining.
Want to read another log on the horizon? Click an ad and support the blog!
Not everything has to be great to enjoyable, whether on page, on screen, or in sound. Serviceable and workaday are fine most of the time. This brings to mind an early Elaine May bit at the 1959 Emmy Awards. She announced the winner of the Total Mediocrity Award: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FyM7AJiC0Nk
ReplyDeleteYeah and I don't want to see "Log Horizon" short. The writing and story construction are really innovative and pulled me into the series. I just wish some extra time had been used to craft more fleshed out characters and maybe a visual design that was a little less standard. if this series disappoints at all, it is because with a little extra care I think it could have been great and something that is easy to recommend.
DeleteI would say it is better than middle of the road anime. I've seen those series. Something like "Sacred Blacksmith" which I honestly don't remember much about at all, except for the sword that turned into a cute girl. "Log Horizon" will always be memorable because of the story construction and use of game mechanics to drive the plot.
I think you hit the nail on the head at least for me, talking about interest waning. Most of the series anime just seem too drawn out for my taste. I prefer the anime movies. I did enjoy Lodoss War and other anime that are more concise though.
ReplyDeleteI'm currently watched Nights of Sidonia, and so far I've enjoyed it. But even then I want it to hurry up and answer all the questions, and also it's a giant mecha storyline so they aren't exactly inventing the wheel. I wish some of these anime studios would just do some adaptations of some lessor known SF novels, but it doesn't look like that's in the cards.
Yeah the pacing can be a real problem, especially with modern anime. I think that "Neon Genesis Evangelion" started that trend of slowing the pacing down, but I think it worked in NGE because the character building was an important part of the theme of the story. In most modern anime the pacing issues turn into more navel gazing and silly cliche moments than actual story of character development. There are exceptions, and I think you could say "Log Horizon" is one of those, but even something fun like "Fairy Tail" had some serious filler episodes that didn't do much at all.
DeleteTighter storytelling was something more common in 80s and 90s anime, but sometimes it would go the other direction. You'd get scenes that would happen without any context, or plot points coming out of nowhere. Some of those 80s OAVs and movies are nearly incoherent at times. Energetic, but confusing as hell. (Part of that may be the poor translations).
But then you get something like "Ninja Scroll" which balances character, storytelling and action almost perfectly - with huge amounts of gore, but still it moves at a great pace.