Introduction:
Color me shocked when I saw
that this movie came out ten years ago. In some ways anime has evolved quite a
bit since 2004. But it also marks the last time that director Mamoru Oshii
helmed a story in the Ghost in the Shell
universe. This film was released after the television series Stand Alone Complex aired in 2002. For
many the television version was the way a Ghost
in the Shell story was supposed to be. But Oshii was going to do what he
does best, and that means tell the story with lots of slow pans, long dialogue
scenes and amazing visuals.
Summary:
It has been a number of
months since the events of the previous Ghost
in the Shell film; Section 9 is still operating as an anti-tech-terrorist
unit, but without the guiding hand of Major Kusanagi (Atsuko Tanaka). Instead
her former partner, Batou (Akio Ohtsuka) finds himself teamed up with Togusa
(Kouichi Yamadera), on a case that appears to involve a serial killer. Someone
is hacking into the cyber brains of servile androids and causing them to kill
their owners. When several of these owners turn out to be prominent politicians
and businessmen, a foreign power is suspected behind the plot.
As Batou and Togusa dig
deeper into the investigation they find that these servant androids are
actually prototype models of illegal sex-roids. Is the company creating them,
Locus Solus, covering up a mistake in the new cyber brains, or is something
more sinister going on? It all leads to a tangle with a yakusa gang, Batou
getting his cyber brain hacked, a house of illusion and a final battle against
an army of killer gynoids aboard a huge ship.
Good Points:
- Some beautiful visual sequences and tense action scenes
- Explores themes and ideas beyond the main plot
- Expands on the world created in the first film
Bad Points:
- Moves very slowly with lengthy dialogue sequences
- Lacks the stand out action sequences of the previous film
- Far removed in tone and tempo from the manga and television series
Overall:
Expectations are the key to
this movie. If you are expecting a solid follow up to the previous Oshii film,
then you’ll be fine with this movie. Just know that it moves much slower and
spends more time philosophizing about existence then ever before. Action hounds
will be disappointed, with the exception of one scene. But animation fans will
have a visual feast, as Oshii creates vivid and memorable settings and
sequences that will stay in your mind long after you’ve seen the film.
Scores
(out of 5)
Visuals: 5
Sound: 5
Acting: 4
Script: 3
Music: 4
Direction: 3
Entertainment: 3
Total: 4
In Depth Review
A killer doll, or a doll made killer? |
But to be very honest here,
Mamoru Oshii takes all the elements that seem to annoy critics of his films and
indulges in them endlessly in this film. I don’t like to use the term
self-indulgent, but in many ways Innocence
feels exactly that. You get the feeling that Oshii is more concerned with
cramming as many quotes from literary sources into his film as possible. Or including
as many scenes with a basset hound as possible. Or having as many long slow
dialogue scenes as possible. It feels excessive. But for all that, it is part
of what makes an Oshii film an Oshii film. I don’t whine about David Lynch
showing another scene of red curtains blowing in the wind, or a blonde with
ruby red lips exhaling smoke in extreme close up. That’s just what he does.
Batou is our hard boiled hero. |
The other major change is
the color palette. It is based on yellows, golds and oranges. This gives the
movie a very unique look, a warm feel at odds with the coldness of the
characters and the direction. Darker scenes end up a murky wash of yellows and
browns. But later in the film, we a dazzling array of gold, copper and
brilliant bronze reflections as Batou and Togusa explore the estate of a hacker
who may have already penetrated their cyber brains. The contrast between the
visual warmth of Innocence and the
cool world of Ghost in the Shell
makes for a striking and interesting contrast. It explains why Oshii felt the
need to go back to his older film and change the hues more toward that warmer palette
(but you can read my thoughts about that little redux over here).
One of many amazingly detailed settings. |
Innocence has
a few action scenes in it. The most impressive is when Batou takes on a whole
building full of gun touting gangsters. The action is fluid and a nice mix of
angles and perspectives. The finale scene also focuses on Batou as he raids a
floating gynoid factory as all the defenses are armed. This includes the
androids themselves: dolls with the ability to smash a man’s head into pulp.
The scene jumps from Batou’s perspective, and his cyber vision feeding him
critical information, to amazingly animated combat. But none of these scenes
are as exciting as the highlights from the previous film.
Sound effects work is
excellent in this film, and it should be considering they got Skywalker Sound
to give them a hand. It really immerses you in the world. The quieter scenes
work great, especially the scenes inside the mansion of illusion. But the
action scenes are a blast, with gunfire seeming to rain all around.
Batou and his guardian angel battle the dolls. |
The DVD I have of this film
is actually in Japanese only, so I have to judge the voice acting as best as I
can. It is the same cast reprising their roles, and they do a fine job with
them. Especially given the fact that they have many long dialogue scenes to
work through.
The journey to the mansion is a visual treat. |
And speaking of quotes,
Oshii decided that Shirow’s original dialogue just didn’t include enough
literary quotes. So he grabbed Bartletts and started highlighting. The result
is a film filled with characters quoting Milton, Confucius and ancient
proverbs. It becomes a bit comical at times, trying to imagine a world where
everyone has extensive knowledge of these texts. The quotes do all end up
working with the themes of the film, so I can’t fault the selection, but I do
end up wondering if Oshii is trying to impress us with these lines, or if he
figured that everything he wanted to say had already been said, so why rephrase
it. It’s an interesting choice, and once that ends up distracting me as the
film continues.
The mansion is filled with reflective and metallic surfaces. |
As the investigation
continues, Batou and Togusa discover that the killer androids all end up
destroying their cyber brains. But one message is clearly found, the single
phrase: “Help me.” This puzzle causes them to wonder who is asking for help,
the killer, the victims, or is it somehow coming from these “dolls”, who are
being mass produced to serve humans as slaves and sex toys. How far does making
something look human go toward giving it a soul? Can a doll be alive?
The blood of the victim obscures Batou's view. |
There is another subtheme
about perception. This is something Oshii has been exploring since his early
days with Urasei Yatsura 2: Beautiful Dreamer. In this film, there are countless shots of eyes, POV shots and
strange shots with fisheye lens effects. You have many scenes of characters
looking and being looked at. And most disturbing are the scenes of the lifeless
eyes of the “dolls” staring at us. These scenes build a visual motif asking us
how do we perceive life. Is it simple enough to trust our eyes to tell us when
something is alive?
Hope you like hound dogs, because this movie is full fo them. |
The mystery is eventually
solved, with the killer being exposed and the murder spree halted. But Batou
wonders about all the “dolls” that were forced to act in such a horrible
manner. What did they feel? Could they feel at all? How many victims were in
this crime?
The bizarre fisheye lens forces our perspective on the scene, and the dead eyed hacker's words. |
So yes, even the scenes with
the basset hound managed to merge with the theme that Oshii is exploring in innocence. As we watch Batou and his
dog stare into the eyes of the doll, we are left wondering if there is a ghost
in that shell.
What the doll sees. |
Innocence
feels like an extension of theme and plot from the first film. But it also
feels a bit redundant thematically. It explores and restates much of what Oshii
covered in the first film, but with longer dialogue scenes, and a slower pace.
Yes, it is a gorgeous film, and the eye candy alone makes it worth seeking out.
But when it was over, I realized why I hadn’t revisited it in nearly ten years.
Ghost in the Shell covered this, and
did it exceptionally well. Innocence plays
like a coda, crafted to suit the creator more than the viewer. It is an
interesting film, but not a necessary one.
And now a selection of various shots of the staring dolls, just to haunt your dreams and retard your sleep.
And now a selection of various shots of the staring dolls, just to haunt your dreams and retard your sleep.
Doll: Evidence in the morgue |
Dolls: Puppets watching Togusa |
Doll: Sacrificial burning during a celebration |
Dolls: They approach in legion |
Doll: Broken and spattered in still warm blood. |
It’s a question we are likely to face eventually as AI improves, and the anime creators may well be right in supposing a major employment of AI will be in sexbots. The gender war always has evoked fantasies of replacing flawed lovers with manufactured perfect ones. I suppose we could start with Pygmalion, but let’s just go back as far as 1987 with “Cherry 2000” and “Making Mr. Right.” (I’ll not try to analyze why in those movies [spoiler] the guy ultimately opts for a real woman but the gal opts for the robot.) Part of the attraction is that it is a form of auto-eroticism, which to steal a Woody Allen line, is “sex with someone I love.”
ReplyDeleteIf you’re not already familiar with it, you might enjoy Charles Stross’ novel “Saturn’s Children,” set in a future in which biological humans have died out because they so preferred their machines to each other that they stopped reproducing. The machines – which continue to exist – arguably have no good reason to stay humaniform (not always a practical design, after all), but they do to maintain their sense of identity – for to change their form would change the essence of what they are. So, in his future the ghosts are pretty clearly there.
I've never heard of that novel, sounds intriguing. Putting androids in human form is a staple of anime. It is rare you see a robot that is designed for function, like R2-D2 in "Star Wars". Most of the anime versions are very human (and usually female). From a writing perspective this makes sense, it is another character to write for and allows the creators delve into the familiar "why am I here, what am I" debate.
DeleteSome of these characters become fan favorites and end up spawning a whole slew of imitators. Rei from "Neon Genesis Evangelion" was one of the most popular characters on the show. As the show starts out, you think she's just a shy girl with no friends and who is only around to pilot the giant mecha. Shinji and the viewer learn more about as the show progresses, and it becomes obvious that the reason she has no friends or family is because she is synthetic. Well, Rei was such a popular character that the pale, quiet, shy robot girl became a staple of late 90s and early 00s anime. Even shows that didn't have any other robots in them had a Rei-alike. I noticed that trend has died out, but it is funny to see how that single character took off.
I have not seen any follow ups to Ghost in the Shell, but I think I've run across them on Youtube and thought of watching them to see how it goes. I saw a anime the other night, which was older called Battle Angel (Alita), and for the most part fits the mold of the robot/cyborg girl. Like most of these animes the English dubbing was off and it was too bombastic for my taste at times, but still was okay on some level for the night.
ReplyDeleteOddly though in that anime it did have a droids that was more an assembly line droid for work.
Yeah, it would be hard to overlook pleasure droids in the further, it just seems logical , ha.
I've run into more and more people that enjoy "Ghost in the Shell" in its television form, "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex" more than the film version. I can understand that, it moves at a faster pace, is closer to the original manga stories, and it has some modernized technological ideas over the first film which was very grounded in 1990s tech. But I think Oshii's visual style trumps the television series n a lot of ways. I think it depends on how you feel as a viewer if you like more plot to chew on, the television series is the way to go.
Delete"Battle Angel" is a fun show, at least I remember it being fun. I haven't seen it in ages. It does have a distinct look to it, very grimy if memory serves. And yeah the dub on that one was an early one and very hit and miss. Funny thing about "Battle Angel", James Cameron is an anime fan from way back. Just check out the mecha in "Aliens" and "Avatar" if you doubt it. ;) Anyway his name has been attached to live action remakes of anime for a while. I remember back in the 90s there was quite a bit of buzz about him tackling a live action version of "Akira". I'm not sure what happened to that concept, but around 95 and 96 I heard quite a bit about it.
Lately, he's talked about adapting "Battle Angel". In fact he was talking about it before "Avatar", and had been working with ILM on designing some concepts. Then after "Avatar" he started talking about it again, but now it seems "Avatar 2" is in the works, and "Battle Angel has been put aside again. Curious to see if he ever gets around to it.
I loved your review Roman. It's a great write-up. Enjoyed it very much.
ReplyDeleteThose visuals are sumptuous, but boy does Oshii love exposition. The man could talk you to death.
It's easy to understand why the folks behind SAC wanted to take the concepts into an action-based arena. The universe is tailor made for it. But at the same time, you have to appreciate Oshii's restrained, philosophical vision. It's a pleasure to have both.
You've got me very interested in revisiting GITS. I just finished Hannibal Season One and I will launch head long into GITS this weekend.
Great stuff.
Also, I would love to see that Cameron Battle Angel film happen. I've waited a long time and then Avatar came along. I'm not much of a fan of it either.
Anyway, you take care Roman.
sff
Thanks for checking this one out! It was neat to revisit the film after all these years. As I watched, those visuals really popped out at me again. Oshii has a great eye for composition and atmosphere.
DeleteSAC is a blast and in a lot of ways, much closer to the graphic novel then Oshii's films ever were. Lots of action in graphic novels, and SAC really captured that. I watched it for the first time at the end of last year and really enjoyed it. Looks like there is a second season too, so I'll need to check that out.