In many ways Star Trek: The Motion Picture suffered
a fate similar to Star Wars: The Phantom
Menace. Both were preceded by a large hype machine. Both had fans eager to
see the continuing adventures of their favorite characters. Both had fans with
very distinct notions of what those adventures should be like. Both films had
directors that were shooting for something much different than the fans
expected. Both got hit pretty hard by the fans upon release. Of course the big
difference is that The Motion Picture didn’t
have Jar Jar Binks.
Summary:
When a mysterious cloud-like
entity destroys three Klingon warships and a Federation space station,
Starfleet becomes a bit nervous. When they determine that the cloud is coming
toward earth they decide to send their flagship, the Enterprise to investigate.
Admiral Kirk (William Shatner) pulls some strings to lead the mission, pushing
aside Captain Decker (Stephen Collins). Along the way they pick up Spock
(Leonard Nimoy) who has determined that pure logic may not be the answer to all
his questions.
The Enterprise confronts the
cloud and with it a strange energy probe that abducts Lt. Ilia (Persis
Khambatta). When it returns her, she appears to be a mechanical replica that
answers to a being called V’Ger. This being has crossed the endless voids to
find it’s creator, and it will stop at nothing to do so. Can the crew of the
Enterprise solve the puzzle of this mysterious being before it destroys Earth?
Good Points:
- Amazing visual effects that still hold up well today
- Jerry Goldsmith provides what I consider his masterpiece of film music
- Captures the awe and vastness of space exploration
Bad Points:
- The characters don’t feel like the familiar group
- The movie takes its sweet time doing anything!
- The plot is recycled and thin
Overall:
This movie needs to be
rediscovered. It is the only Star Trek film
to really embrace the spectacle and enormity of the unknown, and does it in a primarily
visual style. It falls directly in line with the ideals and themes of the
series, and avoids a direct comparison to Star
Wars. While it’s not the best of the series, it is the most ambitious and
most thematic of the films. Once you appreciate what it’s trying to do, the
movie really works.
Scores
(out of 5)
Visuals: 5
Sound: 4
Acting: 3
Script: 3
Music: 5
Direction: 4
Entertainment: 4
Total: 4
In Depth Review
Boldly watching what no man has watched before. |
I will admit the film is
flawed. It could have used a few more passes with the script, and tightened a
few elements down. It could have made the characters feel closer to their
television series versions with a bit more banter and camaraderie. It could
have turned the story into something more crucial to the world of Star Trek, or
to the characters (preferably both). Instead the film focuses on the themes
more than the plot and characters and in that way is closer to 2001: A Space Odyssey than it is to Star Wars: A New Hope.
The Enterprise in the belly of the beast. |
What is interesting to me is
that the special effects created back in 1979 hold up today (for the most
part). So much time and effort went into creating the detailed models, sets,
and assorted visuals that most of them were reused and reconfigured for the
most of the remaining franchise. A whole host of different visual effect
techniques were used, from in-camera tricks, to full-blown composite shots
using state of the art motion control techniques. The director’s cut adds a few
digital clean up scenes here and there. But nearly all of them would have been
possible if the production had a bit more time to smooth things over.
For me it’s the model work
that impresses the most. The Enterprise is beautiful creation, and seeing on
the big screen during its introduction is a real treat. The camera was able to
get incredibly close to the model, because of it’s size (8 feet) and the
amazing detail on it. In addition you have the detailed model for the V’Ger
starship, and immense creation that dominates the middle portion of the film. It is an organic, yet mechanical design
that is menacing and mysterious all at the same time.
The Enterprise is dwarfed by V'Ger. |
For the directors cut in
2001 the intended sound mix was used. The one on the theatrical cut was
actually a temporary track. The intended track actually brings a bit more power
to key scenes. The starship sounds, from the proton torpedoes, to the engine
room rumble are immersive. You also have a whole array of sounds for V’Ger, its
probe and various elements within its inner workings.
The music during the cloud exploration includes plenty of Blaster Beam sound effects |
Unfortunately two elements
are lacking in this film and keep it from top marks. The first is the script.
The plot itself is very simple. Yes, the stakes are high, but there is nothing
really demanding about the situation for the characters. Our main crew of Kirk,
Spock and McCoy (DeForest Kelley) find themselves watching much of the action
in the film and not entirely participating. In fact most of the original crew
gets sidelined in the film.
Guest stars Decker and Ilia get all the action |
Now, Spock and Kirk do have
smaller arcs they work through. Kirk gets his ship back, and comes to
understand what his role is as a leader. Obviously being an Admiral had made
him a bit rusty on this concept. McCoy calls him on not trusting his crew to do
their job and pushing too hard. It results in the ship nearly being destroyed
in a wormhole. Eventually Kirk gets back into his groove and is able to figure
out V’Ger’s puzzle.
The admiral uniform in this film inspired the admiral uniforms in 2013's "Into Darkness" |
For the most part the acting
is solid. The script doesn’t allow much of the banter fans were used to, and so
for many folks the performances seem stiff. However, I’ve always found the
performances to be realistic to the situations that occur before the film. Kirk
has been in what is essentially a desk job, McCoy was retired and Spock had
gone back to Vulcan. So these three would feel a bit awkward around each other.
Things thaw a bit as the film progresses, but everything seems so serious at
times. Nimoy probably delivers the best performance, but his character is given
an actual arc to progress through, so maybe it isn’t fair to judge the others
against his performance.
The probe brings the Enterprise to V'Ger. |
As much of an improvement
the new editing makes, it doesn’t change the fact that Star Trek: The Motion Picture is a slow, slow movie. It takes its
time setting up the simple situation. It takes its time getting us to V’Ger and
then delving into the mystery. I do think the exploration of the cloud
and the being itself are visually impressive, but they really drag the thin
story down. The main problem with the pacing is that it actually ends up
reducing the tension in the film. There is no real urgency here, and it hurts
the finale. I really believe that a few more passes with the script could have
yielded a better result.
The Enterprise survives for further adventures. |
In the end the flaws end up
hurting the film for most viewers. They go in expecting an exciting space
adventure, and instead get a slow moving mediation on man and machine. It’s a
shame too, because I think the elements that set this film apart from other
films in the franchise and to other films of the era are what make it appealing
and fascinating to watch. Star Trek: The
Motion Picture was aiming high, and even its pretentious title seems to
indicating something grand in it’s vision. I admire the creative team for
having lofty goals and creating something unique and interesting. It isn’t a
perfect film and I think that the follow up, The Wrath of Khan is a more entertaining and better executed film.
But for all its faults, this is one trek worth taking and the director’s cut is
the way to take it.
Yes, Jar-Jar definitely would have added another dimension.
ReplyDeleteI never watched the director's cut, so perhaps it' time to revisit this.
Yes, Jar Jar is such a special character... add him to any movie and it automatically becomes a unique experience. :)
DeleteGive the director's cut a shot. The movie is still very slow, but it flows a lot better now. There's been some updates to a few of the effects shots, but they are very subtle and fit well within the context of the film. The remastered sound is also a treat.
Just thinking of Jar Jar Binks makes me feel unwell.
DeleteI purchased the director's cut about a year ago. Yes, it's slow, but still worth watching. The special effects are impressive.
I totally reject the JJ Abrams ST It's NOT STAR TREK ! It's a bad imitation of the universe i grew up with and revere.
ReplyDeleteAny true fan will tell you that.
They need to bring Picard back ! And soon !!!
**** Hailing Frequency Closed ****
Yeah, I know there are fans out there with very strong feelings about the direction Abrams took the franchise. I completely see where they are coming from. He turned "Star Trek" a series that has always been focused on ideas, themes and humanity's role in the universe, into a series about space action and adventure. And yet, the original series had plenty of those rousing space adventure episodes too. True, nearly all of them always tied back to a theme or moral, but there was a feeling of fun to the original series, and the films based off that series that really seemed to missing from the TNG series (not all the time I'll grant you) and films.
DeleteI think that spirit of fun and adventure is something that Abrams brought back to the franchise and made it more accessible to folks who had equated Star Trek to old and stodgy. I think he went a bit overboard, but I know so many folks who are discovering and re-discovering Star Trek because of his films. I can't say that makes me sad.
So my opinion is his two films are entertaining and fun. They take place in their own time line (so the adventures older fans know and love are still relevant). I enjoy them for what they are. But I really hope the next film (or series) in this version of the franchise gets back to some of the more thematic and morality based tales of the original series. I'm sure the cast would be up for it and I know there are some very exciting story to tell.
Thanks for posting!